The patterns of reasoning, political commentary, and standards of judgment that I encounter in public discourse have become a source of profound concern to me. I used to be confident that, notwithstanding our difficulties, we possessed the collective resolve and intellectual capacity to build a better country. I made that case here and here in the past.
I believed that if we managed to get to a point where we supported scientific discovery, invested in innovation, communicated evidence effectively to the public, and equipped the next generation of scientists and engineers to pursue meaningful breakthroughs, we could gradually lay the foundations for a more prosperous society.
I am no longer so certain.
Increasingly, I worry that we lack the intellectual seriousness and moral courage necessary to bring about the transformation we so desperately need.
There is plenty to worry any remotely discerning person about the state of our country, but what I find increasingly difficult to comprehend is the apparent collapse of our collective judgment. Why do Nigerians, including and especially millennials who have inherited the consequences of decades of poor governance, continue to celebrate, defend, and confer social prestige on the very political figures and self-serving power brokers who engineered and/or contributed to those failures?
A while ago, a traditional leader gave what was, at face value, a moving rendition about the children kidnapped in Oyo. I was disappointed at how many obsequious admirers showed up in the comments section of her post, praising her. Though apparently lost on some of these intellectually incurious people, she is a leader, and she is not one of us, the ordinary people. She is part of the political establishment that has presided over and facilitated our country’s moral and institutional decay.
And then there is the establishment capitalist who, for some reason, has become a celebrated, aspirational public figure. We are not unaware that this individual’s accumulation of enormous wealth has been closely intertwined with political decisions, government concessions, and backroom deals, whether legal or otherwise. This individual like many others, enriched himself at our expense! Yet, millennials admire and aspire to emulate this man. I find this astonishing! It also irritates me to no end.
We know these bad actors and we have been trapped on their bridge to misery and chaos for so long, but I am beginning to doubt that we have what it takes to fend them off or mount any meaningful resistance. How are we able to accord any type of deference to these people? Just how? You give them an audience and a public following. Some inveterate loudmouths go so far as to adulate them publicly, while others regard access to them as some sort of social achievement. This is the attitude of beggars and sycophants not people who want their country to thrive. There is a problem here and it’s good for us to at the very least acknowledge it. If you cannot rise up against the looters of your commonwealth, at least shun them! Starve them of your applause!
And what am I to make of those of you who read the memoir of a former military ruler and thought it worthwhile to engage me in discussions about it. If you were alive and politically conscious in the 1980s and 1990s, I cannot understand why you would bother reading this man’s book. What exactly are you looking for? We know who he is and we know what his legacy is. His legacy includes (among other moral abominations) the annulment of the June 12, 1993 presidential election, widely regarded as one of the freest and fairest in our country’s history. What else are you seeking to discover, and why?
I have not read the book, and I have no intention of reading it. You may, of course, tell me why you bothered, and if I am feeling particularly chivalrous, I may even indulge you in a conversation about it. But there are no guarantees.
And then there is a former president whom some of you now affectionately refer to as “Baba.” Ah! What exactly has earned him such reverence?
I struggle to think of any of our former leaders, with the possible exception of General Yakubu Gowon, whose record places them beyond serious questioning about the current sorry state of our country. Whether you realise it or not, these are people who have, in different ways and to varying degrees, exerted a corrosive influence on the political and institutional foundations of our country. Yet rather than interrogate their legacies, we treat their occasional, often ponderous pronouncements on national affairs as though they were disinterested observers of problems in which they themselves played a part. What is the matter with us?
There is also the soul-rotting and civilizationally ruinous tendency to mistake motivational speeches, social prestige, and public visibility for evidence of competence and leadership.
We have a former banking executive who now tells us whom to marry, how to live our lives and offers all manner of life lessons and motivational counsel. You see, one thing I have always suspected is that too many of us are but mere laggards, easily swept away by shallow motivational speeches as well as empty rhetoric and recycled platitudes. You may disagree, but one of the most reliable yardsticks for assessing a person’s leadership potential is their antecedents. What have they actually accomplished? And in what capacity. What tangible results did they deliver when they previously held leadership positions? If someone has already had the opportunity to lead an institution and struggled to deliver satisfactory results, surely that record ought to count for something when we assess their suitability for subsequent leadership positions or socio-political relevance. No?
And then there is the online commentariat and the self-appointed custodians/moderators of public opinion. There is now an endless procession of stance-takers, some of whom, judging by the way they conduct themselves in public discussions, I would go to considerable lengths to avoid in person. Some seem to possess all the biological hardware for aggression but very little inclination towards serious intellectual engagement. Much of what these people offer as serious political commentary is little more than agitprop, delivered with remarkable confidence and very little intellectual substance. Yet, these are the people to whom we increasingly turn for commentary on some of the most consequential issues facing our country.
Now, I am not suggesting that public commentary or the conversations taking place on social media are unimportant. They are, and this is not peculiar to Nigeria. But social media pundits are by no means whatsoever a suitable replacement for thorough, rigorous assessments aimed at understanding precisely what is being done, what is going wrong, and why. There is a real danger of political misdiagnosis when we substitute confident pronouncements and partisan narratives for careful examination of the evidence.
We are not paying sufficient attention to the history that has made us, and we are doing a very poor job of documenting anything worthwhile that could be remotely useful to the next generation. Who is documenting the bad economic ideas and policies that have brought us to this point? Who is examining their consequences? And who is doing the painstaking work of identifying what might actually help us move forward?
If you really care, throw some of your time and resources into supporting serious work in economics, history, science, public policy, and the like. We need experts, researchers, and craftsmen who can use their skills to create and foster relevant, though not necessarily new, conversations about the old, tenacious problems in our society.
We need a greater willingness to examine the evidence, question assumptions, be open to the possibility of being wrong, and follow arguments wherever they lead. We need to invest in people and institutions capable of doing that work, not merely applaud those who have mastered the art of attracting an audience.
Now to some rather curious political preferences.
I find the extraordinary support for one political figure shocking and telling. Against seemingly formidable odds, he has emerged as one of the country’s most celebrated political personalities. Frankly, over the last couple of years, I have marvelled at the standards by which we judge those who aspire to govern us. Its either we are no longer capable of thinking clearly as a people, or we have become so desperate that we are prepared to strike a Faustian bargain, overlooking substantial political baggage simply because someone appears to offer an alternative to the existing order. I am not sure which it is, but I am increasingly convinced that we are on the wrong track towards national repair.
How is it that there are at least 6,101,533 Nigerians who support a man who served on a government-appointed task force under General Sani Abacha! Sani Abacha was a rapacious scoundrel who had the soul of a bully and was exceedingly cruel to us. Surely participating in any capacity whatsoever in an initiative set up by Sani Abacha’s government is a legitimate subject for public scrutiny, even if it does not, by itself, prove political allegiance. To ignore this is to be disingenuous, ignorant and lazy.
Then there is this politician’s record as governor of a state where doctors went on a prolonged strike over an agreed salary structure. Whatever explanations may be offered for that dispute, its consequences for healthcare, and the administration’s responsibility for them, deserve serious examination. What does that episode tell us about how this aspiring leader manages essential public services? These questions should matter enormously when we assess anyone seeking to govern a country as troubled as ours.
The revelations about offshore assets, and whether they were declared, also raise questions of transparency and accountability. Those questions should not disappear just because the person involved has gained an enthusiastic following. Please do not dismiss them.
Perhaps a widespread mental recalibration is possible. I would like to believe so, but I am not holding my breath.
More on this in a subsequent essay.

